J.E. Joyce's "Soot Happens" is a delightful foray into the world of sapphic small-town romance, where the themes of grief, identity, and belonging are explored with both humor and sensitivity. Set in the charmingly quirky town of Sleighbell Springs, the novel invites readers into the life of Maddie Weiz, a widow grappling with the aftermath of her husband's sudden death. Three years on, Maddie is still tethered to his legacy, running the family hardware store and living in their shared home. The narrative deftly captures her internal struggle as she contemplates selling everything to start anew in Boston, a decision complicated by the town's endearing yet intrusive residents.
Enter Jordan Vale, the town's soot-covered chimney sweep and Maddie's late husband's best friend. Jordan is a character who embodies the novel's blend of humor and heart. Their proposal to Maddie—to give the town a month to prove it can be her home, too—sets the stage for a journey of self-discovery and emotional healing. Joyce's portrayal of Jordan as a masc nonbinary lesbian adds a refreshing layer of diversity to the romance genre, and their dynamic with Maddie is both engaging and authentic.
The character development in "Soot Happens" is one of its standout features. Maddie's evolution from a woman trapped in the past to someone open to new possibilities is portrayed with nuance and depth. Her reconnection with her art and the gradual rekindling of her joy are beautifully rendered, making her journey relatable and inspiring. Jordan, on the other hand, is a study in contrasts—confident yet vulnerable, grounded yet restless. Their chemistry with Maddie is palpable, and the transition from friendship to something more is handled with a deft touch, avoiding the pitfalls of cliché.
Joyce's writing style is both witty and poignant, striking a balance that keeps the narrative engaging without undermining its emotional weight. The dialogue is sharp and often humorous, capturing the essence of small-town life with its gossip and camaraderie. Yet, beneath the humor lies a profound exploration of grief and the courage it takes to move forward. The author skillfully weaves these elements together, creating a tapestry of emotions that resonate long after the final page is turned.
The theme of found family is central to "Soot Happens," and Joyce excels at illustrating how community can be both a source of frustration and support. The residents of Sleighbell Springs, with their meddling yet well-meaning ways, provide a backdrop that is as much a character as Maddie or Jordan. This sense of community, coupled with the novel's celebration of queer joy, adds layers of richness to the story, making it more than just a romance but a testament to the power of connection and acceptance.
In terms of emotional impact, "Soot Happens" delivers a satisfying blend of laughter, tears, and warmth. The novel's exploration of love and loss is handled with sensitivity, and Joyce's ability to convey the complexities of moving on is both touching and realistic. The romance between Maddie and Jordan is steamy yet tender, capturing the thrill of new beginnings while honoring the past. The narrative's pacing ensures that the emotional beats land effectively, keeping readers invested in the characters' journeys.
Comparatively, "Soot Happens" shares thematic similarities with works by authors like Casey McQuiston and Talia Hibbert, known for their inclusive and heartfelt romances. Joyce's novel stands out for its unique setting and the depth of its character portrayals, offering a fresh perspective within the genre. The book's focus on a bisexual widow and a nonbinary lesbian protagonist adds a layer of representation that is both necessary and welcome, broadening the scope of contemporary romance.
Overall, "Soot Happens" by J.E. Joyce is a charming and insightful addition to the sapphic small-town romance genre. Its exploration of themes like grief, identity, and belonging is both thoughtful and engaging, making it a must-read for fans of character-driven stories. Joyce's ability to blend humor with emotional depth ensures that the novel resonates on multiple levels, offering readers a story that is as heartwarming as it is thought-provoking. For those seeking a romance that celebrates diversity and the power of community, "Soot Happens" is a delightful choice that promises a hard-earned happily ever after.
